Well, yesterday proved to be a roller coaster of a day as far as the much anticipated iPhone 3G announcement went. I have recently became an apple adopter, but it has been something I planned to do for a long time.
Growing up, and keeping an eye on the options of personal computers, I never understood the reason to have a Macintosh product in my home. Nothing seemed to be compatible with anything I used at home or school. The endless resources of programs that were available on a standard PC, running a Microsoft operating system, were not available on a Mac. That may be an ignorant statement, however for me personally it was a valid statement. I first became interested in the world of Apple when I used one to record a score for a musical at a studio at BYU. I always understood the advantage of using a Mac for multimedia like music and video. I have always know that to properly use ProTools to record my own music I would need a Mac. I never had the money for that so I had no reason to make the transition.
Then I bought an iPod. I was very impressed with the design, and how clean and easy it was. I began to feel like I had sold Apple products short all these years. I mean how can I possibly question a company that brought us devices the Newton!? In all seriousness, Newton aside, I was really considering my next computer purchase to be an Apple computer. I saw wonderful products like the MacMini roll out of the mill. I wanted one before they were even released. I kept watching eBay for PowerBooks in hopes I could get one at a decent price. No such luck. Then one day the MacBook was released with an Intel based processor. I took a second look at the Macintosh line, and found that for what I do with computers I was more capable with a Mac than with a Windows machine. I finally joined the Mac club earlier this year when I purchased a MacBook Pro.
I bought an iPhone the day it was released. I have never been happier with a mobile phone, and again I was blown away by the design and and capability. I did wish it was 3G, but it has been a great device for me for almost a year now. The things I felt were hard to swallow about the iPhone was the AT&T prices that had been set for the iPhone plans. I can’t say I didn’t expect this from a greedy phone provider like AT&T but I had a little hope for the plans to be more affordable. I mean $59 dollars for 450 minutes, unlimited data, and only 200 text messages!? If I wanted unlimited text messages I would have to pay an additional $30. Total $90. With my previous carrier, that price would have got me 900 minutes, unlimited text messages. So I investigated further. Fortunately I have friends who prefer cheaper phone plans too. We all decided to join a family plan which will allow the entire family to get unlimited texting for the same $30 that I would have had to pay for just my line. Once it was all setup and completed I payed $58 dollars a month after taxes and fees to use an iPhone. All 4 iPhone users on my family plan got that rate because we spread the text equally between the 4 iPhone users and another person on the plan not using an iPhone. What I ended up with was 1400 shared minutes of which we use 1100, unlimited data and unlimited text messages. I feel that $60 dollars a month is a fair price. I have been happy with that price, I was a bit pissed that I got nailed with activation fee’s which are retarded and won’t be discussed in this article, but probably should be at another time.
Skip ahead to yesterday. It had been highly rumored that an iPhone with 3G capability would be announced at this year’s WWDC. Along with it there had been high hopes of more functionality to be included in the new iPhone. I personally had hoped for copy/paste functionality, along with the ability to send video or picture messages. Not that hard to program and definitely no need to upgrade the hardware for it. My hopes were dashed during the keynote speech which turned out to be a really long infomercial on the games and crappy programs that people can now put on the phone. They ran right past the place that I hoped would take the most time. New or modified features on the phone were briefly mentioned. Things like a new scientific calculator, which I won’t use, bulk email deletion, the App Store and Exchange integration which we already knew about. Where is flash integration in Safari, internet tethering, or themes and springboard icon mods? I wasn’t too impressed with the new features, and the only thing I would look forward to was faster mobile browsing. The $199 price tag for an 8GB iPhone 3G looked really nice, but I had this feeling that it was too good to be true.
As it turns out it was too good to be true. I visited Apple’s web page, and saw the line that says, “Phone, iPod, and Internet in one fast 3G device. Starting at $199*.” Did you see the asterisk? I sure did. I explored a little further only to find this:

The fine print will get you every time. The phone is only $199 for people that sign a new 2 year contract. I had hoped that I could just buy my iPhone 3G outright and not have to extend my contract, which I look forward to being out of a year from now. I had began to weigh the possibility that I might extend my contract when I read this.
All iPhone 3G customers are required to have one of the new data plans and qualifying voice plan. Customers intending to use the iPhone 3G for access to corporate e-mail, business applications, or access to corporate intranet are required to activate with Enterprise Data Plan for iPhone.
…
Data Pricing will be as follows:
Consumer Data Plan (must be added to qualified voice plan):
$30 - Unlimited Data (E-mail/Web), includes Visual Voicemail
Enterprise Data Plan (must be added to qualified voice plan):
$45 – Unlimited Data with personal and corporate e-mail, web, includes Visual Voicemail
There are two things wrong with this:
1. Data is $10 more a month than it was previously.
I don’t believe that newer technology should be more expensive as a service just because it is better. I know a lot of ISP’s and mobile providers like the one i’m complaining about that disagree based on their track record. I understand cost of providing a service, but when the means of delivering the 3G technology are identical to the 2G technology why are we being charged 50% more for it? Because it’s better? Shouldn’t you charge the same amount and let the consumer move in the direction of the better technology? I know, how un-Capitalistic of me to suggest that.
2. If I want to use Exchange Active Sync using the same Unlimited 3G internet they want me to pay $45 a month?
How is that justified? I own my own exchange server. I own my own iPhone. There is a program on the iPhone called Active Sync that is payed for along with the iPhone. Everything is payed for on the hardware and software end. Now all I need is a means to communicate. That is where the 3G comes in. If I am already paying $30 a month for unlimited use, why would using 3G to work with my Exchange email cost $15 dollars more a month? It’s the same internet as 2G, 3G, DLS or Broadband. There is no magical internet network called Enterprise. The same amount of data will be transfered using POP3 instead of Exchange. There is nothing different about how the information is being transmitted and received over the 3G network, but for some reason AT&T feel they have the right to charge me for it. I call Bullshit.
For those reasons I probably won’t be updating to the new iPhone. I will most likely be leaving AT&T come June 2009 and I will unlock MY iPhone and use it with T-Mobile. Better prices, for the same shitty service. I’ll only be down 3G, but It’s not worth it to me to be ass-raped by AT&T.
I know that nobody but a few people care about this, but I think some things need to change. These companies already over charge us for these services. See GThing’s blog on the True Price of SMS Messages for more of what I mean.
AT&T has a chance to keep me as a customer if they would drop the need to screw me out of the extra $15 to have 3G and Exchange. Oh, they’re not even charging 2G or EDGE users extra to use the Exchange integration of the iPhone, which will be available to me at the same time as the iPhone 3G. God AT&T pisses me off.